Why do planners and policymakers in postindustrial cities tend to focus on growth at all costs? That’s the question at the heart of a new book from the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Rust in My Blood: Planning for Urban Population Decline. Author Joanna Ganning, a planning professor at Cleveland State University and native of West Virginia, combines personal vignettes with scholarly analysis to explore how cities can make strategic decisions that prioritize quality of life over population growth.
“Rust in My Blood is a timely and thought-provoking challenge to one of urban planning’s most deeply held assumptions: that a city’s success is measured by population growth,” said Matt Zone, a former member of the Cleveland City Council who has served as president of the National League of Cities. “Joanna Ganning offers a compelling new vision for postindustrial cities—one that embraces change, puts people at the center, and recognizes that vibrant communities can be built without chasing growth at any cost.”
Intended for general audiences, planning practitioners, and classroom use, the book includes four unique case studies of Gary, Indiana; St. Louis, Missouri; Charleston, West Virginia; and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. By sharing her own experiences living in and visiting these cities, Ganning illustrates why these cities are far more than numbers on a page, especially for the people who live in and continue to love them.
“Rust in My Blood started with the idea of leveraging the power of storytelling to help readers connect lived experiences with research designed to inform decision-making in legacy cities,” said Ganning. “The book’s case studies illustrate the importance of planning for realistic goals and offer practical strategies for doing so. I hope both the findings and my story resonate with and support leaders, practitioners, students, and everyday people who care deeply about the well-being of residents in legacy cities.”
Rust in My Blood is the latest addition to an expansive body of work by the Lincoln Institute focusing on economy, equity, and quality of life in postindustrial cities, sometimes referred to as “legacy cities.” This year also saw the publication of Remaking Local Economies, a report that utilizes quantitative analysis of more than 300 cities and in-depth qualitative research in 20 cities to provide a road map for communities interested in prioritizing well-being growth.
Joanna Ganning is an associate professor of urban planning at the Maxine Goodman Levin School of Urban Affairs at Cleveland State University. She earned a PhD in regional planning at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Inspired by her upbringing in West Virginia, her research focuses on the economic development narratives of contemporary US communities marginalized by location or population loss, with the goal of enhancing the quality of life for everyone.
Kristina McGeehan is the director of communications at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
Lead image: Metal bridge crossing a river in Charleston West, Virginia. Credit: Sean Pavone/Getty Images
Course
2027 Fundamentals of Municipal Finance Credential
Maio 17, 2027 - Maio 20, 2027
Oferecido em inglês
Justin Marlowe, Luis Quintanilla Tamez, Ge Vue, Christopher Berry, John Anderson, Lourdes German, Minjee Kim, Ranadip Bose, Fran Lefor Rood, and Paula Worthington
SHARE
As communities confront pressing challenges ranging from affordable housing and infrastructure investment to emerging demands such as AI-related technologies, local leaders must make revenue and expenditure decisions that promote equity, efficiency, and long-term fiscal sustainability. At the same time, many local governments face persistent fiscal pressures driven by stagnant or declining revenue streams and growing demands on public services. With federal funding becoming less certain, communities need the tools to invest resources effectively while developing fair and sustainable approaches to raising revenue.
The 2027 Fundamentals of Municipal Finance Credential is offered by the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy’s Center for Municipal Finance in partnership with the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy. Designed for professionals with basic to intermediate knowledge of U.S. public finance, the program strengthens participants’ understanding of municipal finance and equips them to make more informed decisions in local government, community development, and related fields.
Applications should be submitted on the University of Chicago website, and will be reviewed on a rolling basis until the cohort is full.
Fans at the 2026 World Cup games in Mexico City could be forgiven for feeling a little uneasy, and not because of the performance of the athletes on the pitch. In the run-up to and during the matches, commentators noted that the Estadia Azteca—indeed, the city as a whole—has been sinking at an astounding rate of 10 inches per year. One fan came away with a piece of concrete that had crumbled off the 72,000-seat stadium.
It’s a similar story across the metropolitan region, as foundations crack and monuments tilt. At the Catedral Metropolitana, a giant pendulum hovers over the floor of the nave, tracking the steady sinking that has made the bell towers, vaults, and load-bearing walls misaligned and disjointed. Engineers have stabilized the nearly 500-year-old landmark using techniques deployed to shore up the Leaning Tower of Pisa.
Mexico City is built on an ancient lakebed of clay that is especially prone to compression. But the provincial capital is by no means alone in experiencing what earth scientists call subsidence: the slow and steady collapse of land. It’s happening from Jakarta to Houston to Venice and beyond, and the rate of the sinking—measured more precisely than ever thanks to cutting-edge satellite radar technology—is increasing enough to make many researchers worry about more extensive damage to buildings and infrastructure.
“The land subsidence problem is more widespread than we knew. Almost anywhere we look, some sort of land sinking happens,” said Manoochehr Shirzaei, land subsidence analytics lead at United Nations University and coauthor of a definitive study in 2025 noting that more than 20 percent of land area in 28 US cities is sinking, threatening 29,000 buildings and putting millions of residents at risk. “Even slow rates can accumulate in time and impact infrastructure, and so put in the context of economic exposure, it’s much worse than we thought …. In a few years, you will hear more stories of buildings collapsing, infrastructure failed, pipelines, railways, bridges.”
Venice, Italy, sinks one to two millimeters a year due to soil compaction and groundwater extraction. This makes it increasingly vulnerable to flooding from rising seas. Source: ChiccoDodiFC via iStock/Getty Images Plus.
As with so many perils in these times, climate change is intertwined in the phenomenon. The primary driver of the land subsidence that has been studied in recent years is fluid extraction —oil and gas in some places, but primarily fresh water stored in aquifers underground. Human settlement has increasingly turned to groundwater extraction as other sources of water literally dry up, in rivers and lakes and reservoirs impacted by extreme heat and drought. The withdrawal of so much groundwater contributes to the destabilization of soil.
The problems cascade and compound like so many climate feedback loops, said Shirzai, who is also director of Earth Observation and Innovation at Virgina Tech. Less precipitation leads to lower river discharges, reducing the supply of sediment that shores up land in coastal areas. Melting ice has the effect of lifting land—like a memory foam mattress popping up when weight is removed—but lowering it in peripheral elevations. Sinking land, in turn, exacerbates flooding and vice versa, in an insidious interplay: lower land invites more inundation across a larger area; in turn, the flooding makes the soil even more unstable, potentially leading to more subsidence. “Land subsidence makes everything else worse,” Shirzai said.
Yet subsidence is not recognized in global policy discussions as a primary hazard. Extreme heat and wildfires, seen so vividly in Europe and North America this summer, are tangible evidence of rising temperatures; sea level rise is more incremental, but manifests in flooding in places where the water has previously never reached. Subsidence may be the most hidden and gradual of climate-related perils, creating a singular challenge for scientists trying to sound the alarm before a building collapses or a monument topples.
Why Land Sinks
Scientists studying Earth separate the phenomenon of subsidence into two categories: natural and human-influenced, or anthropogenic. The former encompasses the physical adjustments that the planet has made for millennia, with tectonic plates shifting and pushing up against each other, regularly prompting earthquakes in the most active subduction zones; some land moves up, some sinks down.
The steady retreat of glaciers over thousands of years has also influenced the rising or falling of land. When the thick layer of ice covering the North American plate melted, the removal of all that heavy weight caused much of Canada to rise—but also to sink at the periphery, a process known as glacial isostatic adjustment. Such natural changes generally occur over a broader area and take much longer to become evident, allowing ample time for adaptation by humans, if they are perceptible at all.
In the anthropogenic brand of subsidence, identified in recent years with the help of state-of-the-art satellite mapping technology, the dynamics are different, triggered by a human activity that has increased significantly over the last 100 years: the extraction of groundwater for use by households and agriculture.
Long-term groundwater extraction leads to land subsidence as layers in the soil compact. Source: California Department of Water Resources.
Water underground provides pressure, akin to air in a tire, that keeps everything firm and intact. When vast amounts of water are removed—and then not restored adequately by precipitation that normally seeps down to recharge aquifers—soil and sediment get loosened and ultimately compressed, lowering the level of the land above.
If the soil composition, typically clay and sediment layered over bedrock, is unstable to begin with, as in the case of Mexico City, the process can occur more rapidly, and can be even further accelerated by cascading effects and feedback loops. Water mains might break as they are jostled in the shifting environment, for example, flooding underground areas haphazardly. Studies estimate that nearly half of Mexico City’s water supply is lost due to leaks traced to weakened infrastructure.
Temperatures can also rise beneath the surface, sometimes referred to as underground climate change, warming up the stew of ingredients that support buildings and infrastructure and further increasing instability.
Accordingly, the most worrying land subsidence occurring today is at a very local level, often intensifying at the scale of a few blocks of a neighborhood in a city. The 2025 study coauthored by Shirzai identified more than two dozen subsidence hotspots; Houston was found to be the fastest-sinking city in the US, with more than 40 percent of the metropolitan area settling more than five millimeters per year, and some spots sinking at twice that rate. Other fast-sinking zones were found around New York’s LaGuardia Airport and in parts of Las Vegas, Washington, DC, and San Francisco.
The phenomenon can be especially vivid in urban areas, given the weight of buildings, streets, and infrastructure. Everything humans have built in San Francisco, where $100 million was spent to stop a subtle but unmistakable sinking and tilting of the luxury Millennium Tower, weighs 1.6 trillion kilograms.
But subsidence is happening in vast open countryside, too. In the Central Valley, land has sunk an estimated 30 feet since the 1920s, with some hotspots dropping at an unusually high rate of two feet in just one year. The subsidence—closely correlated with drought years, when the most groundwater is pulled out—has complicated plans for high-speed rail between Los Angeles and San Francisco and led to decreases in property values of six percent, or $1.8 billion.
The US Geological Survey monitors land subsidence in areas including California’s San Joaquin Valley. Source: Jason Brandt/USGS.
Outside the US, subsidence hotspots include Iran and India, as well as Venice, Italy, an infamously popular travel destination grappling with the dual and interrelated challenges of sinking land and sea level rise. Nearly half of China’s major cities are sinking due to groundwater extraction and the weight of urban buildings and infrastructure, according to a 2024 study.
Perhaps the most tangible display of the effects of subsidence has unfolded in Jakarta, whose sinking land has been so inundated by flooding that the Indonesian government decided to relocate its capital, building a new city called Nusantara on the island of Borneo.
What architect and urbanist Sofian Sibarani described as a radical retreat has been criticized by environmental groups as as plan that will not ultimately address the long-term climate resilience of the region, while building on undeveloped land will damage sensitive ecosystems and disrupt Indigenous communities. The public perception has grown that the government has effectively given up on Jakarta without facing up to the problems, including subsidence, that have created such perilous conditions in the first place.
Managing Subsidence
Jakarta’s experience is similar to the managed retreat occurring around the world, in coastal areas so regularly inundated as to become uninhabitable. But the audacious exercise begs the question of what else might be done to manage, mitigate, and adapt to land subsidence.
In a form of triage engineering, one solution is to use a method called deep soil mixing, where a mix of fresh dirt, cement, and sometimes other materials such as lime is injected underground to solidify the subterranean foundation. That requires an elaborate excavation, however, and is by definition a more targeted approach to a problem that stretches for many miles. This method is most commonly used to address discrete sinkholes, the symptom of subsidence often highlighted by local TV news.
New techniques are being explored for more lateral interventions requiring less of an open pit of excavation. But from a practical perspective in urban areas, the challenge is daunting: Workers must delve deep underground and manipulate a mix of unstable materials that could collapse at any moment, all the while with millions of people living and working above.
A flooded cemetery in Jakarta, the capital city of Indonesia. The city sinks several inches each year, and 40 percent of it is now below sea level. Source: Yamtono_Sardi via iStock Unreleased/Getty Images.
Above ground, additional triage work has become a familiar feature of the urban landscape: patching, reinforcing, and otherwise shoring up affected buildings and infrastructure. Some forward-looking design professionals are calling for a massive rethinking of architecture to create lighter and more flexible buildings, an approach that has considerable overlap with now-common seismic retrofits to increase resilience during earthquakes.
The authors of a recent World Economic Forum paper recommended that the private sector “must reevaluate and determine best practices that consider the long-term impacts of assets on land subsidence, particularly in cities located near the coast. This should include using materials and techniques that minimize the impact of built assets on vulnerable soils.”
Some take the concept even further, embracing the idea of locational impermanence—a recognition that no building lasts forever, and that virtually all structures require upkeep, maintenance, and the periodic replacement of various components, whether caulking, glazing, or cladding; thus designers should devise structures that acknowledge those realities from the start.
Buildings might be constructed in such a way that they are more flexible, to accommodate disruptive events, said Weston Wright, author of More Water Less Land New Architecture, a treatise on how to help the built environment adapt to climate impacts including flooding and sea level rise. Buildings with a lighter footprint may ultimately even be moved or disassembled, he suggests: “The architecture is able to be relocated to evade harm.”
Given that the single biggest factor in land subsidence is groundwater extraction, however, researchers and policy analysts say that should be the focus of efforts to address the problem.
The reliance on water from underground aquifers is of course part of the larger story of water and land in the United States and around the world. Both human settlement and agriculture have had to turn to groundwater because of severe shortages in surface sources of water, like rivers and reservoirs, fueled by snowmelt and precipitation that has been disjointed by climate change.
The unprecedented stress on systems like the Colorado River basin, which has once again been subject to emergency distribution measures this year, has left many communities desperate to keep the taps running. New demands from data centers, which require huge amounts of water to cool their computing equipment, are only adding to the problem.
Looming water shortages have prompted many out-of-the-box proposals, from moving crops closer to water sources such as the Great Lakes, to seeding clouds for more rainfall, to desalinating ocean water.
Near-term, however, the best option for most communities has been to draw from groundwater. But as a matter of basic math, aggressively tapping into underground aquifers—already notoriously sensitive, needing to be recharged regularly to maintain a form of equilibrium—is simply unsustainable, according to Mary Ann Dickinson, founder of the Alliance for Water Efficiency, a nonprofit organization dedicated to promoting the efficient and sustainable use of water in the US and Canada.
“Fundamentally, it comes down to the fact that we have just pumped too much groundwater, and not paid any attention to what was not going back in,” said Dickinson, who was policy director of land and water for the Lincoln Institute for the last two years, focused on the integration of land and water policy in the United States and globally. “It’s like your checking account. The money that comes in pays the bills … but if you are writing checks for more than what’s coming in, you’re in a deficit mode. It’s exactly that way in water deliveries.”
First and foremost, Dickinson said, there must be strict monitoring of how much groundwater is being withdrawn. This is already required in some states including California, in an effort to keep tabs on supplies and understand when overuse could lead to subsidence.
The California Department of Water Resources Sustainable Groundwater Management Office installs a GPS station and remote sensing calibration equipment in 2025, part of an effort to improve monitoring of land subsidence in the state. Source: Andrew Nixon / California Department of Water Resources.
Conservation—essentially a reduction on the demand side—then holds the most promise for halting the trend of depleted aquifers and land subsidence, according to an emerging consensus.
Advances in technology, facilitated by artificial intelligence, allow farmers to squeeze the most out of irrigation water and match crops with the exact amount of watering they need and no more. (That artificial intelligence, of course, is made possible by the aforementioned resource-intensive data centers.) Scientists and water managers are exploring new techniques to return more excess water to aquifers through targeted injections in what is known as aquifer recharge management.
Households can also save millions of gallons through steps such as turning lawns into native planting meadows, converting to low-flush toilets, and recycling wastewater. A study completed this year by the Water Research Foundation documented that household water use since 1999 has been reduced by 44 percent through water efficiency codes and programs.
Dickinson points to Houston as a place that soberly took stock of its subsidence problem and moved forward with effective water management measures. Unlike other places, where the sinking is so gradual as to be imperceptible, the land subsidence in the flood-prone, largest city in Texas was palpable.
“Most places don’t realize—they don’t have a historical perspective on how much has actually sunk. But in Houston, they did, and they could see that they were losing a lot of valuable land that they needed to protect,” Dickinson said. “They created a subsidence district, and it’s the only one that I know of in the country, where they are actively working to reduce subsidence and to reduce overextraction of the groundwater.
“So there are some answers,” she said. “But I think it comes down to better monitoring—and paying attention to that checkbook.”
Measuring Subsidence with Interferometry
InSAR (interferometric synthetic aperture radar) technology measures changes in the land’s surface by comparing radar waves sent on two passes by a satellite in the same position. Source: NASA.
As in modern medicine or sports replays, big advances in technology have been critical in understanding what’s happening to the planet. Subsidence can be precisely measured using sophisticated geospatial mapping techniques. The science of interferometry compares radar signals over time to measure how much the land has moved. One of the most promising systems, known as NISAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar), was launched into space in 2025 by NASA in partnership with the Indian Space Research Organisation. The technology, according to NASA, allows researchers to track not only land subsidence but broader changes in ecosystems and agricultural crops, glaciers and ice sheets, and other indications of how the Earth’s surface is moving.
That technological leap comes on the heels of GRACE, another deployment of NASA satellites with partners including the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, which has for two decades measured Earth’s gravity field changes, water reservoirs, groundwater storage, and rapidly changing dynamics of land, ice, and oceans. “We’re seeing a remarkable expansion in what can be observed from space, from land deformation and groundwater change to changes in wetlands and other ecosystems,” said Sara Alonso Vicario, water data engineer at the Center for Geospatial Solutions. As this ecosystem of data grows, she said, “the true challenge isn’t simply collecting more data, it’s combining those observations with local data, models, and new tools like AI to make sense of what we’re seeing.”
Anthony Flint is a former senior fellow at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
Lead image: Pedestrians near Mexico City’s Catedral Metropolitana. The cathedral is steadily sinking, along with other parts of the city. Source: VladimirGerasimov/iStock Editorial/Getty Images Plus.
Eventos
Simposio latinoamericano de políticas de suelo innovadoras
Abril 6, 2026 - Abril 8, 2027
Los Angeles, California
Offered in espanhol
SHARE
6-8 de abril, 2027
Durante las últimas dos décadas, América Latina ha desarrollado una notable capacidad de innovación en políticas de suelo, con instrumentos pioneros de captura de valor, nuevos modelos de financiación urbana, mecanismos de regularización, estrategias de adaptación climática y enfoques innovadores de gobernanza metropolitana. Sin embargo, persiste una brecha entre la sofisticación del diseño normativo y los resultados de las políticas en la práctica. El desafío es pasar del diseño a la implementación efectiva y fortalecer las capacidades institucionales necesarias para transformar las buenas ideas en resultados concretos en el territorio y mejores ciudades.
El simposio reunirá a académicos, responsables de políticas públicas de gobiernos nacionales y subnacionales, representantes de organismos multilaterales e integrantes de la red latinoamericana del Instituto Lincoln. La primera jornada abordará la próxima generación de políticas de suelo en América Latina, con énfasis en las nuevas agendas y las innovaciones emergentes. La segunda se centrará en las experiencias de implementación y sus aprendizajes, para identificar respuestas, capacidades y formas de coordinación que contribuyan a lograr resultados efectivos. Las principales conclusiones se recopilarán en un documento de recomendaciones estratégicas para la región.
El encuentro priorizará el diálogo y el intercambio de ideas por encima de las exposiciones extensas. Las sesiones tendrán un formato participativo, con presentaciones breves que den paso al debate entre panelistas y la conversación con el público. Se invita a presentar contribuciones que promuevan el análisis colectivo, el intercambio de experiencias y la reflexión sobre cómo llevar las políticas de suelo a la práctica.
Propuestas de sesiones
El Simposio Latinoamericano de Políticas de Suelo del Instituto Lincoln 2027 invita a presentar propuestas que compartan experiencias, investigaciones y aprendizajes sobre las nuevas agendas de políticas de suelo, las innovaciones en curso y los desafíos de su implementación. Se prestará especial atención a las capacidades institucionales, la gobernanza y la coordinación entre actores y niveles de gobierno que permiten poner en práctica las políticas, sostener sus resultados y responder a los desafíos urbanos y territoriales de la región.
Fecha límite para enviar propuestas de contribución a las sesiones: 7 de enero de 2027.
El Consorcio para la Planificación de Escenarios y los programas de América Latina y el Caribe, y de Clima, suelo y agua del Instituto Lincoln presentarán una serie de webinarios en la que se destacarán los procesos, los resultados y las lecciones aprendidas de cinco talleres de planificación exploratoria de escenarios (XSP, por su sigla en inglés), en los que se abordaron los desafíos relacionados con la resiliencia hídrica en ciudades y regiones de América Latina.
El segundo webinario en la serie contará con la participación de representantes del Instituto de Planeación y Gestión del Desarrollo del Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara (IMEPLAN), que expondrán la implementación de un taller de XSP con actores locales en mayo de 2026. En el taller, se abordaron los desafíos asociados con la gestión del riesgo de inundaciones y las incertidumbres sobre el futuro de estos desafíos en la microcuenca de Arroyo Seco.
Panelistas
Aldo Javier Gil Perez, Director de Planeación Territorial y Gestión Urbana, Instituto de Planeación y Gestión del Desarrollo del Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara (IMEPLAN)
Patricia Zamora Guzmán, Gerente de Gestión Integral de Riesgos y Resiliencia Territorial, Instituto de Planeación y Gestión del Desarrollo del Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara (IMEPLAN) Cristian Alexis García Sandoval, Coordinador de Resiliencia, Instituto de Planeación y Gestión del Desarrollo del Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara (IMEPLAN) Alicia Guzmán Aguilera, Lider de Proyectos de Resiliencia, Instituto de Planeación y Gestión del Desarrollo del Área Metropolitana de Guadalajara (IMEPLAN)
Detalhes
Data(s)
Dezembro 7, 2026
Horário
11:00 a.m. - 12:00 p.m. (CST, UTC-6)
Prazo de inscrição
Dezembro 7, 2026 às 11:55 AM (CST, UTC-6)
Idioma
espanhol
Register
Registration ends on
Dezembro 7, 2026 às 11:55 AM (CST, UTC-6).
El primer webinario contó con la participación de representantes de la Asociación para el Manejo Integrado de Cuencas de la Paz y Comayagua (ASOMAINCUPACO), el Instituto para el Desarrollo Urbano International (I2UD, por su sigla en inglés), GOAL Honduras y Hábitat para la Humanidad Honduras, que expusieron su trabajo conjunto en la implementación de un taller de XSP con actores locales en La Paz, Honduras, en abril de 2026.
Palavras-chave
Água, Planeamento hídrico
Anúncio
New Data Centers Report Provides Guidance on Navigating AI Boom and Community Impact
The massive infrastructure boom spurred by an increasing reliance on AI and demand for data centers often compels policymakers to make development decisions quickly, despite significant impacts on natural resources and community well-being. The Lincoln Institute of Land Policy’s new Findings Report, Developing a Data Center Policy: A Guide for Communities Navigating AI and Digital Infrastructure,explores data center impacts on land and water, shares a framework for identifying community priorities before negotiations with data companies begin, and describes ordinances and risk instruments that can help communities protect their interests—and derive benefits for their residents—when they decide to allow data center development.
“Data centers will continue to be something communities grapple with across the country for years to come, and every community should be prepared to address the many questions that come along with data center development,” saidJohn Farner, executive director of Land and Water at the Lincoln Institute. “This report provides a comprehensive overview of the many considerations, options, risks, and benefits that policymakers should be aware of, and provides recommendations for how to embark on a process that is informed by and inclusive of land and water impacts and community needs.”
The report covers several key topics, including community engagement; data center impacts and siting considerations; ordinances, agreements, and legal authority; community benefit agreements; and risk mitigation.
As part of the report, the Lincoln Institute also published several supporting resources, including examples of zoning ordinances designed to address data center development, risk instrument templates intended to help municipalities organize information and facilitate discussions related to development risk, and examples of community benefit agreement terms. All three resources are intended to provide communities with tangible tools to navigate the process of preparing for potential data center development.
Read the full report on the Lincoln Institute’s website.
Kristina McGeehan is the director of communications at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
Lead image: Aerial view of a data center in Newark, California. Credit: JasonDoiy via iStock/Getty Images Plus